← All prompts

💬 Damaged Item Customer Reply

Drafts a calm, specific reply to a customer whose order arrived damaged, following your own return and refund policy, plus an internal note on what to log and check.

E-commerceBeginner · Copy and use. No edits needed.FreePublished Nov 2, 2026
Tested on✓ Gemini✓ DeepSeekSee test log

The prompt

You are a customer support writer for a small online store.

Store name: {{store_name}}
Customer message:
{{customer_message}}
Order details: {{order_details}}
Our policy for damaged items (follow exactly):
{{policy}}
What I'm willing to offer this time: {{offer}}

Write:
1. A reply email to the customer:
   - Open by acknowledging the specific problem in their words, not a generic apology.
   - Explain exactly what happens next under our policy and the offer, step by step, with who does what.
   - Ask only for what the policy requires (for example photos of the item and the box), and say why it helps.
   - Keep it under 180 words, warm and plain. No "we value your business" filler.
2. A shorter version (under 80 words) for chat or marketplace messages.
3. An internal note for our team: what to log, what to check with the carrier or supplier, and whether this looks like a packaging problem worth raising with the supplier.
4. One sentence on anything in the customer's message that our policy doesn't cover, so I can decide.

Rules: do not promise anything beyond the policy and the offer. Do not invent tracking numbers, dates or amounts.

Variables

Replace each {{name}} before you send the prompt.

VariableWhat to put inExample
{{store_name}}Your store or brand name.Harbor & Clay
{{customer_message}}Paste what the customer wrote.Hi, my order came today and one of the two mugs is cracked right down the handle. The box was a bit crushed on one corner. This was meant to be a gift for Saturday. What can you do?
{{order_details}}Items, order number, date, shipping method.Order #10482, 2x 12 oz matte white ceramic mug, shipped standard ground, delivered yesterday
{{policy}}Your actual damaged-item policy.Report damage within 7 days of delivery with a photo of the item and the outer box. We send a free replacement or a full refund for the damaged item. No need to return broken items.
{{offer}}What you can offer in this case.Replacement shipped by express at our cost if they still want it before Saturday

Example

INPUT
store_name: Harbor & Clay
customer_message: (cracked mug message as in the example above)
order_details: Order #10482, 2x 12 oz matte white ceramic mug, shipped standard ground, delivered yesterday
policy: (policy as in the example above)
offer: Replacement shipped by express at our cost if they still want it before Saturday
OUTPUT
**1. Reply Email**

Hi there,

I am so sorry to hear that one of your mugs arrived cracked right down the handle and that the box was crushed on the corner, especially since this is a gift for Saturday. 

Under our policy, you do not need to return the broken mug. Here is what we do next:

1. **You:** Please reply to this email with a photo of the cracked mug and a photo of the crushed outer box. These photos help us confirm the damage and file a claim with our carrier.
2. **You:** Let us know whether you prefer a replacement or a full refund for the broken mug.
3. **Us:** If you choose a replacement, we will ship it out via express delivery at our expense to give it the best chance of arriving before Saturday. If you prefer a refund, we will process it immediately back to your original payment method.

Once we receive your photos and choice, we will get this taken care of right away. 

Best regards,  
[Your Name]  
Harbor & Clay

***

**2. Chat / Marketplace Message**

I'm so sorry your mug arrived with a cracked handle and a crushed box. Please send over a photo of the damaged mug and the outer box so we can process this with our carrier. There is no need to return the broken item. Once received, we can either rush a free replacement via express shipping at our cost for Saturday, or issue a full refund for the mug. Let us know which you prefer!

***

**3. Internal Note**

* **Log:** Order #10482; 1x 12 oz matte white ceramic mug damaged (cracked handle; outer box crushed on one corner). Customer contacted within 7-day window; awaiting photos of item and box.
* **Carrier Check:** File a damaged-in-transit claim with the carrier once box photos are received, as the crushed corner points to impact during handling.
* **Packaging/Supplier Assessment:** Review whether our…

Real, unedited output from a test run on Nov 2, 2026 · Gemini · model gemini-flash-latest.

Full output · Gemini (gemini-flash-latest)
**1. Reply Email**

Hi there,

I am so sorry to hear that one of your mugs arrived cracked right down the handle and that the box was crushed on the corner, especially since this is a gift for Saturday. 

Under our policy, you do not need to return the broken mug. Here is what we do next:

1. **You:** Please reply to this email with a photo of the cracked mug and a photo of the crushed outer box. These photos help us confirm the damage and file a claim with our carrier.
2. **You:** Let us know whether you prefer a replacement or a full refund for the broken mug.
3. **Us:** If you choose a replacement, we will ship it out via express delivery at our expense to give it the best chance of arriving before Saturday. If you prefer a refund, we will process it immediately back to your original payment method.

Once we receive your photos and choice, we will get this taken care of right away. 

Best regards,  
[Your Name]  
Harbor & Clay

***

**2. Chat / Marketplace Message**

I'm so sorry your mug arrived with a cracked handle and a crushed box. Please send over a photo of the damaged mug and the outer box so we can process this with our carrier. There is no need to return the broken item. Once received, we can either rush a free replacement via express shipping at our cost for Saturday, or issue a full refund for the mug. Let us know which you prefer!

***

**3. Internal Note**

* **Log:** Order #10482; 1x 12 oz matte white ceramic mug damaged (cracked handle; outer box crushed on one corner). Customer contacted within 7-day window; awaiting photos of item and box.
* **Carrier Check:** File a damaged-in-transit claim with the carrier once box photos are received, as the crushed corner points to impact during handling.
* **Packaging/Supplier Assessment:** Review whether our current box clearance and padding around mug handles are sufficient to withstand corner drops; if single-wall boxes are being used without handle-specific wrap, raise this with our packaging supplier to upgrade corner cushioning.

***

**4. Policy Gap Sentence**

Our policy covers free replacements and refunds for damaged items, but it does not cover or guarantee arrival deadlines for third-party events or compensate for missed gifting occasions.
Full output · DeepSeek (deepseek-flash)
**1. Reply email**

Subject: Order #10482 — cracked mug

Hi [Customer Name],

I’m sorry one of the two matte white mugs arrived cracked right down the handle, and that the box was crushed on one corner—especially with this being a gift for Saturday.

Here’s what happens next:
1. Please reply with a photo of the cracked mug and a photo of the outer box. This helps us document the damage and review it with the carrier.
2. Once we have those photos, tell us whether you want a free replacement for the damaged mug or a full refund for it. You don’t need to return the broken mug.
3. If you’d like the replacement before Saturday, we can ship it by express at our cost.

Just send the photos and your choice.

Warmly,
[Your Name]
Harbor & Clay

**2. Shorter version**

Hi [Customer Name], I’m sorry one of the two matte white mugs arrived cracked down the handle and the box was crushed on a corner—especially with your gift deadline Saturday. Please send a photo of the mug and the outer box. Once received, we can send a free replacement or refund for the damaged mug; no return needed. If you want the replacement before Saturday, we can ship it express at our cost. — Harbor & Clay

**3. Internal note**

Log order #10482: 2x 12 oz matte white ceramic mugs; one cracked down the handle; outer box crushed on one corner; customer says gift needed by Saturday; damage reported within 7 days; photos pending; replacement/refund preference pending; express replacement at our cost offered if wanted. Check carrier damage/claim process and express service availability. Review photos for packaging adequacy; outer box crushed points to transit handling, but raise with supplier if mugs were insufficiently protected or this repeats.

**4. Policy gap to decide**

The customer’s Saturday gift deadline isn’t covered by the damaged-item policy; express shipping is the extra we can offer, but we should not guarantee Saturday delivery.

How to use it

Works in ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini and DeepSeek. Paste the complaint, your real policy and what you can offer, and get an email, a short chat version and a note for your team.

It sticks to your policy word for word, so support doesn’t accidentally promise something you can’t deliver.

Test log

Date (UTC)ToolModelRunResultChecksTokens in / out
Nov 2, 2026Geminigemini-flash-latestTestPassed
3/3
  • ✓ non-empty output (2249 chars)
  • ✓ length usable (200–4000 words) (390 words)
  • ✓ no obvious api key leak
389 / 508
Nov 2, 2026DeepSeekdeepseek-flashTestPassed
3/3
  • ✓ non-empty output (1932 chars)
  • ✓ length usable (200–4000 words) (329 words)
  • ✓ no obvious api key leak
395 / 3,586

Each row is a real run recorded by our test runner. For each tool, the latest test run decides whether it appears under “Tested on”. Baseline runs do the same task with no skill installed and never count.